On May 6, Tumblr user Endophallus Party posted this fatuous comparison of a Tumblry nerdy girl to “other girls”:

“Other girls are girly, I’m nerdy” is a common Tumblr theme, specifically visual comparisons like the above, which has variations like this, this, and this. But this one, as Brad O’Farrell at Modern Primate points out, was a parody. The author said so. And it sparked spinoffs (spins-off?), often from people who took Endophallus’s first picture seriously.

The spinoffs took two forms. Know Your Meme and Modern Primate have explored the first type: Slashfic that shows the two girls above (now named Creamsicle and Other Girls-Sempai) falling in love.

The other type specifically parodies the above. And that’s what we’re looking at today.

Cat with a penis, by Luke:

 

Cthulhu, by Alizabith:

 

Other dudes, by The Sexy Erdgeist Suite:

 

Other Robots, by Puny Bottlecap Life:

 

Other grills, by Minato Baby:

 

Homestuck Hulk, by Cylo:

Homestuck, as referenced above, is a webcomic also known as MS Paint Adventures. A lot of the Other Girls artists here are Homestuck fans. A lot of them link to their DeviantArt pages from their Tumblrs. It’s a certain young, female-heavy overlap of these three cultures.

This one uses two characters as they appear in Homestuck (source unknown, found on Know Your Meme):

No clue.

 

Psycho killer, by Visually Pleasing:

 

Cephalopod, by Lizzorasaurus:

 

Other cats, by empty-10:

 

Other gods (Thor and Loki), by Angela Mercedes:

 

Other killers, by ComicKittyCity:

Remember to check out Brad O’Farrell’s discussion of the Creamsicle meme based off this same original drawing.